SYRIA: MSF suspends support to East Ghouta hospitals after violent incursion

Tuesday, May 2, 2017 — During the afternoon of 29 April, makeshift hospitals supported by the international humanitarian medical organisation Doctors Without Borders (MSF) were subject to outrageous breaches of respect as intense fighting erupted between armed opposition groups in the besieged Damascus suburbs of East Ghouta. As an ‘in-extremis’ measure to underscore that such attacks on healthcare will not be tolerated by MSF, nor by the medics MSF supports, MSF will suspend its medical support to the East Ghouta region until there are clear signs that the fighting parties will respect healthcare.

Reports from doctors MSF supports in the area outline grave incidents on 29 and 30 April in which armed groups showed absolutely no consideration for the special protected status of patients, medical facilities and health workers. Approximately 30 masked and armed men stormed into the Hazzeh hospital on 29 April to seek out specific wounded patients and seized the hospital’s ambulance. A few kilometres south, Aftares medical point was hit by bullets as fighting surrounded it for two days, its medics trapped and unable to collect the wounded, even those lying within sight of the hospital, or to evacuate to a safer area.

The East Ghouta rural zone near Damascus has been besieged by Syrian Government forces since early 2013. MSF has been providing remote support to the majority of health facilities in the area and has built a strong relationship with the medics, helping them to maintain their space for impartial medical care as well as providing them with medical support, both technical and material. Intense fighting between opposition armed groups erupted on 28 April, the conduct of which has shown no consideration for the special protected status of medical care.

 “On behalf of the doctors we support, MSF condemns in the strongest terms the armed incursion into a health facility by masked individuals, the intimidation of health workers, and the seizing of an ambulance,” said Brice de le Vingne, MSF Director of Operations. “Also of grave concern is the sustained heavy shooting by two armed groups at and around a functional hospital. Speaking over the deafening sound of gunfire, the nurses running the small Aftares medical point told us that their facility has been hit by bullets, that they have managed to treat a few wounded, but they can only perform minor surgery and dressings, and that they are not able to negotiate an evacuation of their patients to better-equipped facilities.”

Medical spaces are protected under international law and must remain a place of humanity in war, treating everyone - civilian or not - on the basis of their medical need alone. We will speak out to defend the protected nature of medical spaces and to underscore the need to prioritise the protection of patients and medical staff. We have issued clear demands to the armed groups operating in the East Ghouta area, assuring them that MSF’s considerable medical support to the zone will be suspended until there are clear signs that belligerents will take precautions to ensure the respect of patients, medical facilities and health care workers alike.”

These incursions into health facilities and obstruction of health care come at a time when lifesaving medical care is needed most; a nearby MSF-supported field hospital that has so far been able to continue functioning received more than 100 wounded patients during the two days of intense fighting on 29 and 30 April alone.

MSF calls on all armed groups in the Syria war, whichever side they are fighting on, to respect the protected nature of medical spaces and the protection of patients while under treatment. This means avoiding bombing or shelling them and desisting from armed incursions, intimidation of medics, theft of ambulances and hospital supplies, and attempting to seize or kidnap patients under medical care.

The demands of MSF to the armed groups in the East Ghouta area are listed below:

  1. No weapons or people bearing arms to enter medical facilities.
  2. Patients must be considered as outside of the conflict and due precautions must be taken by fighting parties to avoid direct action against healthcare or hitting healthcare in their crossfire, or any other military acts that might jeopardise patients’ medical care.
  3. The transport of wounded and other patients regardless of their identity, as well as the unobstructed movement of ambulances must be permitted and facilitated.
  4. Medical facilities, their goods and supplies, and ambulances must never be used for military purposes.
  5. Unobstructed evacuation of patients and medics when they need to move to a safer area must be permitted.

MSF directly operates four health facilities in northern Syria and provides support to more than 150 health facilities countrywide. In East Ghouta, MSF supports 19 field hospitals, 2 maternity units, 7 primary healthcare centres, and 5 small medical posts. Many of these are fully MSF-supported, and some are supported by a variety of aid organisations including MSF. Over just three months from November 2016 to January 2017, these facilities performed 291,000 ER and outpatient consultations, 18,750 surgical operations, and 3,100 safe deliveries. MSF accepts no governmental funding for its work in Syria, in order to be demonstrably independent from political motives.

The last two functional ambulances in Al-Marj neighbourhood (in the East Ghouta besieged area near Damascus) were destroyed beyond repair in an aerial bomb attack on Monday 05 December 2016. They were parked in the hospital’s warehouse/garage, very near to the makeshift hospital’s location. Two hospital cars, used to transporting supplies and medical personnel, were also destroyed in the blast. The lack of ambulances will have an impact on the ability to quickly treat wounded when there is bombing or shelling in the area, but above all it will affect the capacity to refer the most sick patients to larger secondary referral hospitals. The makeshift hospital in Al-Marj is not equipped for complex or long-term in-patient hospital care, and this could have a big impact on the ability to refer patients for appropriate secondary care. Photographer: MSF
Doctors and surgeons treat the wounded in a operating theatre set up in a makeshift hospital in an east Damascus neighbourhood. Photographer: MSF
Damaged hospital car<br/><br/>The last two functional ambulances in Al-Marj neighbourhood (in the East Ghouta besieged area near Damascus) were destroyed beyond repair in an aerial bomb attack on Monday 05 December 2016. They were parked in the hospital’s warehouse/garage, very near to the makeshift hospital’s location. Two hospital cars, used to transporting supplies and medical personnel, were also destroyed in the blast. The lack of ambulances will have an impact on the ability to quickly treat wounded when there is bombing or shelling in the area, but above all it will affect the capacity to refer the most sick patients to larger secondary referral hospitals. The makeshift hospital in Al-Marj is not equipped for complex or long-term in-patient hospital care, and this could have a big impact on the ability to refer patients for appropriate secondary care. Photographer: MSF
Bomb damage to the upper floors of the abandoned school building used as a makeshift hospital in a beseiged neighbourhood of east Damascus.<br/>Photographer: MSF